Idaho Execution Error Sparks Lethal Injection Review
TL/DR –
Idaho’s attempt to execute one of the nation’s longest-serving death row inmates, Thomas Eugene Creech, failed after multiple unsuccessful attempts to tap into a vein for lethal injection. Creech, who has been in prison for 50 years and was sentenced to death in 1983 for murder, was returned to his cell after the botched attempt. Amid a series of failed executions across the US, some states, including Idaho, have been exploring alternatives to lethal injection, like the use of firing squads or nitrogen gas.
Failed Execution Attempt on Idaho’s Longest-Serving Death Row Inmate
Executioners in Idaho halted their attempts to use lethal injection on one of the nation’s longest-serving death row inmates, Thomas Eugene Creech, on Wednesday due to unsuccessful vein access. This failure marks Idaho’s first botched execution in over a decade, adding to a string of similarly failed attempts across the country. The issue often stems from executioners struggling to find suitable veins for injection.
Alternatives to lethal injection, such as nitrogen gas and firing squads, have been explored amidst legal pressures. Idaho recently approved the use of firing squads for capital punishment. Following the unsuccessful execution, Creech’s lawyers filed a motion to prevent further execution attempts and criticized the Idaho Department of Correction for their failings.
Thomas Creech, 73, has been in prison for 50 years, serving a death sentence since 1983 for murdering a fellow inmate. His lawyers previously attempted to prevent his execution on grounds of unconstitutional sentencing by a judge, not a jury, which the U.S. Supreme Court rejected.
The execution attempt began at 10 a.m. Medical workers used vein finders, hot compresses, and blood-pressure cuffs to access veins, primarily targeting his arms and legs. However, they ultimately concluded that there were vein quality issues, according to Josh Tewalt, the director of the Idaho Department of Correction.
Despite the failed execution, Tewalt expressed appreciation for the team’s efforts and their commitment to dignity and professionalism. The state is now considering its next steps.
This incident occurred just a month after Alabama executed a prisoner with nitrogen gas for the first time in U.S. history. However, the execution was reported to be inhumane by witnesses, further fueling the debate on capital punishment methods.
Reprieve US, a nonprofit opposing the death penalty, called the botched execution another demonstration of the inherent brutality of the death penalty. Many states continue to struggle with execution schedules due to difficulties in obtaining lethal drugs, despite growing numbers of states banning the death penalty. Idaho was also one of these states, but managed to procure the drugs after passing a law in 2022 that protects the identity of the drug suppliers.
Despite the botched attempt, Idaho continues to explore its options, including the use of a firing squad. However, according to Tewalt, the state lacks the capacity to implement this method at present, and changing state law would be necessary to make nitrogen gas an option.
—
Read More US News