Trust in U.S. Government Economic Data Wanes amid Controversies and Revisions

Determining the Health of the American Economy Without Relying Solely on Government Data

In light of recent controversies, including the downward revisions to employment data, political accusations, and termination of the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ top official, many question the reliability of official U.S. government data. If we cannot trust this data, how can we accurately gauge the state of the American economy?

The Role of the Bureau of Labor Statistics in Evaluating Economic Health

For years, reports from the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) and similar agencies have provided detailed portraits of U.S. economic health. These reports, analyzing aspects like employment levels and inflation, guide decisions for businesses, investors, and policymakers. However, obtaining this data is a complex task, particularly for a rapidly changing economy like the U.S. The most recent jobs report, which showed significant downward revisions to job growth, highlighted the difficulty in acquiring accurate data.

Identifying Economic Trouble Without Relying Solely on Official Data

If the credibility of official data is doubtful, what signals can illustrate economic trouble? Several alternative indicators can give us insight into the health of the economy without consulting official statistics. Let’s explore some of these telltale signs anyone can monitor.

Signs of Economic Distress Beyond the Numbers

1. Labor Market Conditions

Various factors in the labor market can provide early indications of an economic downturn, including:

• Visible Unemployment Increase: More people are seeking work, companies are laying off employees, and “help wanted” signs are less frequent.
• Wage Stagnation: If wage increases are not common, it can reflect a broader economic issue.
• Part-time or Gig Work Increase: Full-time jobs can often transition to part-time or contract jobs during an economic downturn.

2. Consumer Behavior and Social Signals

Changes in consumer behavior and social life can indicate shifts in the economy.

3. Business Activity

When an economy is struggling, businesses often reflect this trouble quickly. Signs to look out for include:

• Layoff Announcements: Companies announcing layoffs can signal industry distress.
• Excessive Inventory and Discounting: Retailers may offer significant discounts or hold clearance sales if they have an excess of unsold goods.
• Small Business Closures: An increase in empty storefronts, business liquidations, or local establishments shutting their doors.

4. Alternative and Composite Data

If government data is mistrusted, indices from private sector and international organizations can provide invaluable insights.

• ADP Private Payroll Data: Private payroll processors, like ADP, provide independent snapshots of employment trends.
• Human Development Index (HDI) and Genuine Progress Indicator (GPI): These measures integrate health, education, and income measures to provide a broader sense of economic well-being.
• Well-being Indexes and Social Metrics: Life expectancy, educational attainment, and poll-based “happiness” measures often capture public sentiment and living standards in ways GDP and job stats alone cannot.

5. Public Mood and Media Reporting

• Media and Social Media: Headlines dominated by stories of job losses, business failures, or personal financial hardship could signal underlying distress.

While skepticism of government data is understandable, there are many ways to gauge the health of the economy. Pay attention to local businesses, listen to stories from regular people, and keep track of movement in the private sector. The signs are rarely hidden; they are, for better or worse, all around us.

Note: This article was created with the help of generative AI. An editor verified the accuracy of the information before publishing.

Introducing the 2025 Fortune Global 500, the definitive ranking of the biggest companies in the world. Explore this year’s list.